The Rotax 912 series engines are highly regarded in the aviation community, especially within the light sport and ultralight categories. The Rotax 912ULS and Rotax 912iS are two popular variants, each offering distinct benefits depending on the application. Here’s a comparison of the two and why one might be considered better than the other in certain contexts:
Rotax 912ULS
- Type: Carbureted, normally aspirated
- Horsepower: 100 HP
- Fuel System: Dual carburettors
- Weight: Slightly lighter than the 912iS due to the simpler fuel system
- Fuel Efficiency: Good, but less efficient than the 912iS, particularly at cruise settings
- Simplicity: The carbureted system is simpler and easier to maintain for those familiar with traditional aircraft engines
- Availability: Parts and support are widely available due to the engine's popularity
Rotax 912iS
- Type: Fuel-injected, normally aspirated
- Horsepower: 100 HP
- Fuel System: Electronic fuel injection (EFI)
- Weight: Slightly heavier due to the fuel injection system and associated electronics
- Fuel Efficiency: Significantly more efficient than the 912ULS, especially at cruise power settings, thanks to the precise control of the fuel mixture provided by the EFI system
- Performance: Offers smoother operation, better throttle response, and more consistent performance across various altitudes and temperatures
- Emissions: Produces lower emissions compared to the carbureted version, aligning with modern environmental standards
- Diagnostics: Equipped with advanced engine monitoring and diagnostics capabilities, making it easier to identify issues and optimize performance
- Operating Costs: Potentially lower over time due to better fuel efficiency, although initial costs may be higher
Benefits and Considerations
-
Efficiency and Performance: The Rotax 912iS is generally considered better in terms of fuel efficiency, performance, and environmental impact. The fuel injection system allows for more precise control of the air-fuel mixture, leading to improved fuel economy and more consistent engine performance under varying conditions.
-
Maintenance and Simplicity: The Rotax 912ULS is preferred by those who value simplicity and ease of maintenance. The carbureted system is familiar to many mechanics and pilots, making it easier to maintain without the need for specialized equipment or knowledge.
-
Cost: The 912iS, being a more advanced engine, typically comes at a higher initial cost compared to the 912ULS. However, the long-term savings on fuel and potentially lower operating costs might offset this difference.
-
Environmental Considerations: For operators who are concerned about emissions and environmental impact, the 912iS offers a clear advantage with its lower emissions and better fuel economy.
Conclusion
The choice between the Rotax 912ULS and 912iS depends on the specific needs and priorities of the operator. If fuel efficiency, modern technology, and lower emissions are priorities, the Rotax 912iS is the better choice. However, if simplicity, lower initial cost, and ease of maintenance are more important, the Rotax 912ULS may be more suitable.
Both engines are highly reliable and well-regarded, so the decision ultimately comes down to the specific use case and preferences of the pilot or aircraft operator.